0

For example, assuming a vegan has no particular religion preventing them from eating pigs: if a pig dies because of an external event or accident, would cooking and eating the pig be consistent with vegan practice?

To clarify, no one has killed the pig with the intention of eating them, they just died.

  • 4
    I'm voting to close this question as off-topic because not informative to the audience – Darrin Thomas Feb 1 '17 at 5:10
  • 1
    I am voting to close, this is likely to spark opinionated debate rather than a meaningful answer – Steve Feb 1 '17 at 6:17
  • 1
    The same can be asked for humans falling from a rock, would you eat it? It's dead anyway. – kenorb Feb 1 '17 at 13:32
  • 4
    @DarrinThomas This may not be informative to you, or people who are already vegan, but if I recall correctly, this forum is also meant to be for people who are new to veganism and have questions (ethical or otherwise). Closing a question because it's not informative to level 5 vegans isn't a great way to help grow the community (which I'm sure we both want :) Now, the opinionated debate thing, I'm not sure - but there's always going to be disagreements on ethical questions. Does that mean we should just avoid talking about ethics? I don't think that's a great idea – user116 Feb 1 '17 at 13:46
  • 2
    Maybe you're right and the debates wouldn't be productive, but I'm just not so sure - most people on here seem to be friendly and thoughtful. – user116 Feb 1 '17 at 13:49
6

Pre-preface: If I recall correctly, ethics questions are on topic on this forum (correct me if I'm wrong). So this questions seems fine. Some vegans are annoyed/frustrated by ethics-based hypotheticals (probably because they're often asked by trolls), but I find them interesting and I think they're a good way to build a strong ethical foundation.

Preface: Most ethical vegans (a tautology by most definitions) are concerned about reducing suffering (of those beings which have the capacity to suffer) by abstaining from consuming products which contribute to the demand for more suffering. I'm going to answer this question from that perspective.

Answer: You ask "is a vegan allowed to eat the pig". This assumes an absolute set of agreed-upon rules which governs the behaviour of all people who call themselves vegan. Obviously this doesn't exist, but if we use our assumptions from the preface, then the answer depends only on one question:

Will eating the pig cause more suffering? If so, don't eat the pig.

Veganism is just an extension of ethics to one's diet and lifestyle.

In light of this, your question may just as well be: Is it okay for vegans to eat any sentient being that was killed by some accident?

Whatever the question, we need only think about the most ethical choice given the circumstances of the actual situation.

So to answer your question: It's depends on the specific circumstances. Of course, most vegans wouldn't eat the pig (just like they wouldn't eat a dead child), but in some bizarre (though conceivable) situation where eating the pig was the most ethical choice, an ethical person would of course eat the pig.

| improve this answer | |
  • +1, but I think "more suffering" is not the only ethical consideration and there might be non-ethical reasons why vegans would not eat the pig – Zanna Feb 1 '17 at 9:11
8

This is the kind of tiring hypothetical omnivores throw at vegans just to troll us, but I find it is usually better to answer them seriously, so:

Why it's probably better not to eat the pig

If I do not eat the pig, it may be eaten by other humans who would normally buy farmed meat, thus reducing demand for such meat.

If not, it may be eaten by other animals (carnivores) whose interests I consider important as a vegan (animal ally?).

If that's not the case, it may be decomposed by micro-organisms which return nutrients to the soil.

| improve this answer | |

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.